Design a web mockup for a comments page

Status: Closed
Prize: $108
Entries Received: 28
Winner: syamjayaraj

Winner

Contest Brief

Hi, I run a website that receives a lot of responses. The comments section are built on top of spot.im right now, but we want to build something custom and something that fits our goal. We usually receive extra-long comments. Each comment might receive responses of its own (secondary level comments)

The attached file, Image#1.jpg, represents a very basic idea that I have in mind. Imagine that that's how the first order responses look like. Second order comments could be grouped together either by indenting or by using panels. The idea has been demonstrated in Image#2.jpg.

Now, I need a mockup design for the comments are organized. The following things should be given consideration.
1. Top-level comments
2. Second-order comments
3. How multiple second-order responses are organized. (Ideas include color bands for each top level comments, numbering etc.)
4. The placing of the comment reaction (smile, neutral, frown)
5. Responsiveness — Design for the web, mobile and tablets.

Feel free to innovate and make changes to the original design. Do not send me copyrighted material or something that's existing. Be creative here. Although separate designs for desktop, tablet, and mobile is optional, if your design satisfies all the conditions above, you will have a higher chance of winning this contest.

If you have any queries, you can let them be known through the public comment board.

Recommended Skills

Winner

Post a Contest Like This

Employer Feedback

“This freelancer brainstormed and came up with a good design. Great work!”

Blizzerando, India.

Top entries from this contest

syamjayaraj India

0
MochRamdhani Indonesia

0
WilDesignZA South Africa

0
chiku789 India

0
sajidesigner Pakistan

2
jay198829 India

0
jay198829 India

1
jramos India

0
syarifmahzumi12 Indonesia

0
jay198829 India

0
zonicdesign Bosnia and Herzegovina

0
WilDesignZA South Africa

0
chiku789 India

0
jay198829 India

0
jay198829 India

0
mawogmanik Bangladesh

0

View More Entries

Public Clarification Board

chiku789
- 6 years ago
no placement of emojis still selected as the winner .i doubt the authenticity of this contest .
- 6 years ago
1. Contest Holder
  - 6 years ago
  Hello, the freelancer has agreed to build on this design and add the missing pieces. The two-column layout is personally something I had never thought of. It works particularly well with the extra long responses we receive.
  - 6 years ago
jay198829
- 6 years ago
please check my entry #23
- 6 years ago
jay198829
- 6 years ago
please check my entry #23
- 6 years ago
Contest Holder
- 6 years ago
Update: Keeping the contest open for a couple more days. I will provide feedback for the new entries later today.
- 6 years ago
Contest Holder
- 6 years ago
Hey all,
Today is the last day of the contest. I look forward to receiving more creative entries today. Brainstorm and you will have more chances of being rewarded :)

BTW—Thanks to everyone who have sent their awesome entries. All the entries that I've rated 4 stars meet the basic requirements and will be considered while choosing the winner of the contest.
- 6 years ago
View 1 more message
1. jay198829
  - 6 years ago
  I'll Create more option your design please open your contest...
  - 6 years ago
2. jay198829
  - 6 years ago
  My All Design Fully Editable PSD File Totally Custom Design... Any Change ya Editing layer wise design
  - 6 years ago
jay198829
- 6 years ago
please check my entry #23
- 6 years ago
zonicdesign
- 6 years ago
Can you check #17 , if you want something to change just tell me i will do it :)
- 6 years ago
joinwithsantanu
- 6 years ago
Please check #10 and put your valuable feedback.
- 6 years ago
jay198829
- 6 years ago
fully editable design making layer wise
- 6 years ago
jay198829
- 6 years ago
Hello Please check my entry #11 #12 #13
- 6 years ago
muditbhutani
- 6 years ago
Are you fine with sketch app file ?
- 6 years ago
1. Contest Holder
  - 6 years ago
  Yes, sure.
  - 6 years ago
jay198829
- 6 years ago
I will create more entries .... so open your contest.
- 6 years ago
1. Contest Holder
  - 6 years ago
  What do you mean by open the contest?
  - 6 years ago
2. Contest Holder
  - 6 years ago
  More entries are definitely welcome tho!
  - 6 years ago
jay198829
- 6 years ago
thanks
- 6 years ago
Contest Holder
- 6 years ago
Upgraded to Guaranteed. Looking forward to more entries. :)
- 6 years ago
Anurag87
- 6 years ago
#guaranteed
- 6 years ago
jay198829
- 6 years ago
#guaranteed
- 6 years ago
jay198829
- 6 years ago
#guaranteed #guaranteed
- 6 years ago
wabdesigner
- 6 years ago
#guaranteed
- 6 years ago
jay198829
- 6 years ago
please check my entry #5
- 6 years ago
xsquare
- 6 years ago
#Sealed please
- 6 years ago
jay198829
- 6 years ago
Only PSD Design?
- 6 years ago
1. Contest Holder
  - 6 years ago
  Hi Tirth, We are replacing spot.im with our own comment application (and not the spot.im design). I am looking for a mockup design for the comments app.
  
  So, I am just looking for a PSD design of the comments section. And not the actual css/template — that maybe for another contest.
  
  I would love everyone to brainstorm and make a design that looks great on a desktop, tablet and a mobile-sized screen. (3 mockups) I hope that answers the question.
  - 6 years ago
jay198829
- 6 years ago
So header and footer similar your site and middle section design for comment page right please give me reply
- 6 years ago
jay198829
- 6 years ago
It's your live website spot.im and comment page this add right
- 6 years ago
Orko30
- 6 years ago
What would be the deliverables? PSD file?
- 6 years ago
1. Contest Holder
  - 6 years ago
  Yes, PSD is okay too :)
  - 6 years ago