Logo Design for EvaluRater

Public Clarification Board

• 

  vrd1941

  • 12 years ago

  God bless you. Great. Congratulations ! Keep it up.

  • 12 years ago
• 

  alwe17

  • 12 years ago

  congrats dyv !

  • 12 years ago
• 

  naashthebest

  • 12 years ago

  Congratulation dyv... :)

  • 12 years ago
  1. 

     dyv

     • 12 years ago

     Thank you. good luck in future projects

     • 12 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 12 years ago

  Thanks everyone for helping to bring my new project to life. Your input was greatly appreciated. I shared the project with quite a few people too who were impressed with the standard and I suspect more projects will be heading this way.
  
  Thanks again.

  • 12 years ago
  1. 

     naashthebest

     • 12 years ago

     You are welcome!!! And thank you for the great appreciation. :) We, freelancers really love to work with people who appreciate our work like you do. Thank you!

     • 12 years ago
• 

  eeshu

  • 12 years ago

  Congratz dyv.

  • 12 years ago
  1. 

     dyv

     • 12 years ago

     thanks!

     • 12 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 12 years ago

  Got it down to 13 designs from 7 designers - logotrak, naashthebest, Ferrignoadv, pinky, dyv, twindesigner, rahulvyas12 and promop. Embarking on the final cull.

  • 12 years ago
  View 11 more messages
  1. 

     rahulvyas12

     • 12 years ago

     I didnt copy this design from others.
     Its my original idea.

     • 12 years ago
  2. 
     Contest Holder

     • 12 years ago

     @ eeshu - I don't think it's so clear that the best work always wins. One tries to pick the best but best is tricky to define with creative work. I definitely know I've rejected some nice work that's for sure. I've rejected some pretty poor work too of course..standard is very variable.

     • 12 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 12 years ago

  4 designers, 5 designs. Cycling home now. Tested it internally in the office and everyone liked different ones. Sigh.

  • 12 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 12 years ago

  I'm curious. Hypothetically would you prefer
  a) to have one winner who gets the whole prize
  OR
  b) to have the prize split proportionately between those designers who contributed to the winning design*
  
  (* assuming there was a mechanism for determining this level of contribution to the winning design...)

  • 12 years ago
  View 6 more messages
  1. 

     rahulvyas12

     • 12 years ago

     IT would be great if you choose option B

     • 12 years ago
  2. 

     Ferrignoadv

     • 12 years ago

     B

     • 12 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 12 years ago

  Picking winner on Monday...Need the weekend to think about this..

  • 12 years ago
  1. 

     existenz33

     • 12 years ago

     I will be happy if you select mine project, but i wish of everyone- luck and success :)

     • 12 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 12 years ago

  Last day of the contest. There's some very nice work here. Difficult to pick a winner (and a bit impractical given the public nature of the designs and how good ideas from one designer naturally get absorbed by others).
  What I'll be trying to do is get a shortlist which I'll then test using a short survey. I'll then pick the winner based on survey results plus the body of work of the designer as opposed to simply picking one nice design.
  It might take a couple of days to organise this and fully digest all the designs.
  
  Sorry for cruelly rejecting so many nice designs. Thanks again everyone for contributing.

  • 12 years ago
  View 1 more message
  1. 

     paalmee

     • 12 years ago

     by the way it can be modified to one star only or different arrangement or different fonts ,, just look at the main idea of the logo %_% cheers.
     best regards,
     paalmee.

     • 12 years ago
  2. 

     argiriano

     • 12 years ago

     I agree with your 5 star rate for #390 and #66 if you think it`s appropriate count my vote for these two! ;)

     • 12 years ago
• 

  eeshu

  • 12 years ago

  Hi
  this is a contest and there will be a single winner.......but if you want to choose more than one or appreciate more than one designer's work then you have to increase your prize money to be distributed.
  this is my point of view.
  
  thanks
  eeshu

  • 12 years ago
  View 1 more message
  1. 

     liaqatalee

     • 12 years ago

     hi dear

     • 12 years ago
  2. 

     vrd1941

     • 12 years ago

     Dear Contest Holder,
     #473

     • 12 years ago
• 

  Zubairthreaded

  • 12 years ago

  Feedback for #456

  • 12 years ago
• 

  twindesigner

  • 12 years ago

  check my new entries #390 and #392 Best regards!

  • 12 years ago
  1. 

     topcoder10

     • 12 years ago

     nice one!! like it a lot :)

     • 12 years ago
  2. 

     liaqatalee

     • 12 years ago

     hi dear

     • 12 years ago
• 

  rahulvyas12

  • 12 years ago

  twindesigner What font you use ?Can I please know?

  • 12 years ago
  1. 

     topcoder10

     • 12 years ago

     yes, he will let you know after the contest ends :P

     • 12 years ago
• 

  twindesigner

  • 12 years ago

  please check #433 with more spacing arround middle R

  • 12 years ago
• 

  dasilva1

  • 12 years ago

  check my new entries #412 #413

  • 12 years ago
• 

  twindesigner

  • 12 years ago

  or #392 with the same color for font

  • 12 years ago
• 

  twindesigner

  • 12 years ago

  please check #390 Best Regards !

  • 12 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 12 years ago

  Mentioned this a few times. I would prefer to emphasise the middle "r" (or "R") in evalurater/evaluRater. I don't particularly want to emphasise "evalu" or "rater" as the business is not about sticking those two words together. Many designs however do do this and stick evalu on to rater. I must say often it looks fine but visually I'm more after emphasising the middle R (eg evaluRater) rather than EVALUrater or evaluRATER.

  • 12 years ago
• 

  rahulvyas12

  • 12 years ago

  Please see #366

  • 12 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 12 years ago

     Seen it. Rated it. It's still in there. Thx.

     • 12 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 12 years ago

  Just done a major cull, so one last note - I'm trying to only emphasise the middle r.
  
  For example I'd like to see "evaluRater" as opposed to "EvaluRater" or "evaluRATER" or "EVALUrater". The middle R could be emphasised through being upper case when everything else is lower case or through being a different colour, or indeed in some other way..
  
  The reason is because I want people to see "evaluater" within the logo as well as "evaluRater".
  
  Many designers have gone for sticking Evalu onto Rater but whilst many of the designs are attractive and I've marked them highly because of that, design wise it's not exactly what I'm looking for.

  • 12 years ago
  1. 

     rahulvyas12

     • 12 years ago

     You didnt like any of my Design?

     • 12 years ago
  2. 
     Contest Holder

     • 12 years ago

     I thought #120, #174, #176 and #366 were good and I liked them. I thought #175 was good but didn't like it so much. I thought there was a lot of creativity around but design is always very subjective. With 369 entries I've had to reject a lot of designs sadly..

     • 12 years ago
• 

  twindesigner

  • 12 years ago

  #349 sorry the new concept with a magic wand

  • 12 years ago
• 

  twindesigner

  • 12 years ago

  check please my new entries #348 and a new concept with a magic wand #348 ( not sure this is what u're looking for )

  • 12 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 12 years ago

  Remember - no swooshes.

  • 12 years ago
• 

  spontaneous

  • 12 years ago

  how about frog! will that be ok instead of aligator?

  • 12 years ago
  View 3 more messages
  1. 

     dyv

     • 12 years ago

     see another animals... you have big ZOO :)

     • 12 years ago
  2. 
     Contest Holder

     • 12 years ago

     Frog looks alright actually (not so keen on the typeface tho). The mastodon is maybe a bit too retro. Lion has gravitas..quite liked that but being brutal now and only kept the frog as I prefered that.

     • 12 years ago
• 

  spontaneous

  • 12 years ago

  a good designer knows how to copy and thats how almost every artist out there does. a painter cant paint if an object isnt infront of him/her, we are not talking about abstract art here.
  even companies pay the designers to copy other designs.now for logo designers choice is limited and competition is tough so they want to win by any means.i must say even if you copy other designs
  do not post exactly the same and bring your some brain or imagination into it to make it even better. thats all guys...

  • 12 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 12 years ago

     Fair points. It's inevitable that one is influenced by good ideas and other's creativity. Ideally straight copies are avoided though. It's tricky to judge as the contest holder though when someone uses stock images that then appear in several designs - I did not realise people were posting designs which incorporated stock images.
     
     For obvious reasons I guess I'd prefer a design with no stock images but I acknowledge illustrating an alligator is a big job..
     
     Anyway - as mentioned the alligator is NOT essential..
     
     Thanks all..

     • 12 years ago
• 

  dasilva1

  • 12 years ago

  check my entry #245

  • 12 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 12 years ago

  Hi everyone - a few more entries than I expected. Am just going through rating them and there's some quite impressive new thinking (and some prolific designers in existence).

  • 12 years ago
• 

  FirstDesign

  • 12 years ago

  Please check #319 and #320 .Best Regards.

  • 12 years ago

Show more comments