Short film needs DVD illustration in a COMIC BOOK or GRAPHIC NOVEL style

Public Clarification Board

• 
  Contest Holder

  • 9 years ago

  First off all... thank you all for your submissions. It sucks someone had to win... and EVERYONE else had to lose.... but me and Addam have budget for just one design and we have made our decision. We tried to have an open and honest dialog with you all... specifically the top contenders to had the best chance to win... but your designs fell short of the winner in OUR opinion.
  
  I wish you all good luck. Thanks again for participating... Derek

  • 9 years ago
  View 13 more messages
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 9 years ago

     From a buyer's perspective, projects are a mixed bag. I've had projects drag on for MONTHS once a person was awarded... with little or no recourse. I once awarded a winner based on his portfolio... and went on to suck.. and suck badly on his deliverables. If I asked for revisions, he would want more money. Contests demonstrate you can take direction AND deliver on time with high quality. It keeps guys like me... who post jobs.. happy. Because I was done with Freelancer based on those experiences. Now I can tell all my filmmaking buddies and fans of this film to come here without hesitation.
     
     Last but not least... I will totally hit u up Monkey in the future. I saw your blog... Mecha Girl.. .Amazon Warrior... lots of cool stuff... much respect. Talk soon.... Derek

     • 9 years ago
  2. 

     DanielKons

     • 9 years ago

     I don't want to extend a lot this but I get clarify what I said... It's really allowed to give feedback, but it's not a professional behavior. I think everyone that keep sending designs, despite have great talent, are beginners and don't know how to valorize them own works. It's like you do a film for a festival, but the festival ask you to change the script and remake some scenes and them award another movie... You had bad experiences with freelancers, but usually the portfolio and experience are enough to know if the work is gonna go well or not. The basis of the work is the previous brief. If the freelancer doesn't keep the agreements and quality, unfortunatelly, you did a bad choice, he's not a professional.... But if you ask something beyond the brief, it's normal to want more money. If you'd ask me changes in composition in this contest, I'd respectfully deny, for instance.
     Regards.

     • 9 years ago
• 

  mannytabontabon

  • 9 years ago

  traced, smudged then blur...

  • 9 years ago
  1. 

     enpclavio

     • 9 years ago

     and that's how you do comic book nowadays LOL

     • 9 years ago
• 

  enpclavio

  • 9 years ago

  Oh well, my design does not get any feedback and rating. sad.
  It seems the chosen artwork does not resemble any graphic novel or comic book pattern?

  • 9 years ago
  View 1 more message
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 9 years ago

     ... and it looks like a comic book to me

     • 9 years ago
  2. 

     nobinkurian

     • 9 years ago

     Sadly the winner has done only Photoshop works from a still from the movie trailer :(

     • 9 years ago
• 

  xixoseven

  • 9 years ago

  hmmmm...

  • 9 years ago
• 

  antoniopiedade

  • 9 years ago

  i was submitting my design when the winner was chosen, but here it is #116

  • 9 years ago
• 

  enpclavio

  • 9 years ago

  * final revision (you can request for unlimited revisions) - #110
  * will look like this on cover - #111

  • 9 years ago
• 

  mannytabontabon

  • 9 years ago

  i just noticed this project yesterday

  • 9 years ago
• 

  mannytabontabon

  • 9 years ago

  can you extend this?

  • 9 years ago
• 

  DanielKons

  • 9 years ago

  Do you have a producer logo or something to send to us?

  • 9 years ago
• 

  mannytabontabon

  • 9 years ago

  pls check 104 sorry it took me a long time drawing it

  • 9 years ago
• 

  monkeybread

  • 9 years ago

  #103 I won't get a chance to do any more polishing on this before the deadline, damn day job. So this is the final. Still can see some things I can work on, but it's pretty close to done.

  • 9 years ago
• 

  kendor

  • 9 years ago

  #85

  • 9 years ago
  1. 

     antoniopiedade

     • 9 years ago

     sorry kendor for mistake i put the number of your submission on my message

     • 9 years ago
  2. 

     kendor

     • 9 years ago

     :) No problems

     • 9 years ago
• 

  nobinkurian

  • 9 years ago

  added #100 th

  • 9 years ago
• 

  xixoseven

  • 9 years ago

  sorry for uploading many submission just checking the color variation ^_^ I hope you like it ^_^

  • 9 years ago
• 

  antoniopiedade

  • 9 years ago

  HI
  Im still working on my design, many details missing yet but #85 heres one preview of the work, i will finish it before the end the dead line for this contest. the composition of the informations (name producers etc...) still unfinished just mount it up to get the filling. If you have any sugestions please do it.
  Thank you

  • 9 years ago
  1. 

     antoniopiedade

     • 9 years ago

     sorry my mistake the number of the image is #89

     • 9 years ago
• 

  enpclavio

  • 9 years ago

  #84 here's mine, from alien to man. LOL. hope no one mimics my idea again. :P

  • 9 years ago
• 

  neriomones

  • 9 years ago

  Hello all,
  Please review #83 and let me know your thoughts.
  Thanks!
  Nerio

  • 9 years ago
• 

  xixoseven

  • 9 years ago

  #82 working in progress ^_^ I hope I can make it on time

  • 9 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 9 years ago

     Sent you a private message

     • 9 years ago
• 

  antoniopiedade

  • 9 years ago

  STILL FINISHING MY illustration this is going to be a close call...

  • 9 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 9 years ago

     Looking forward to it :-)

     • 9 years ago
• 

  nobinkurian

  • 9 years ago

  #73 , HAND DRAWN

  • 9 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 9 years ago

     Sent you a private message

     • 9 years ago
• 

  gravity12345

  • 9 years ago

  plz find #69 and plz give some comments

  • 9 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 9 years ago

     Not our movie. It just isn't.

     • 9 years ago
  2. 
     Contest Holder

     • 9 years ago

     #69 : DVD cover should give reference to the actual movie that lies inside. Don't you think? This cover is misleading. It would be like putting a Terminator on the outside of a romantic comedy

     • 9 years ago
• 

  neriomones

  • 9 years ago

  Hello all,
  Please review #64 and let me know your thoughts.
  Thanks!
  Nerio

  • 9 years ago
• 

  bamz23

  • 9 years ago

  #59 work on progress...pls give some comments...look at the full view!...tnx! :)

  • 9 years ago
  View 1 more message
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 9 years ago

     We want a gritty comic book cover... not a cartoon character. You cover should look like a comic book you would TAKE from a small child. It should not look like a comic book that your BUY for a small child

     • 9 years ago
  2. 

     bamz23

     • 9 years ago

     whoah...haha..tnx...i took some preferrences from punisher and dark knight...bt i think it doesnt turn well! xD

     • 9 years ago
• 

  kendor

  • 9 years ago

  Hello. I'm also on scene :) #53

  • 9 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 9 years ago

     No movie stills from the movie please. We want an illustration and done like a comic book.

     • 9 years ago
• 

  neriomones

  • 9 years ago

  Hi LVVideo1,
  Please review #57 and let me know your thoughts.
  Thanks!
  Nerio

  • 9 years ago
  1. 
     Contest Holder

     • 9 years ago

     Sent you a private message

     • 9 years ago
• 

  xixoseven

  • 9 years ago

  #58 ^_^

  • 9 years ago
  View 1 more message
  1. 

     xixoseven

     • 9 years ago

     it looks like some artsy fartsy-seinen- graphic novel ... just trying new ideas ^_^ thanks

     • 9 years ago
  2. 
     Contest Holder

     • 9 years ago

     Sent you private message

     • 9 years ago
• 

  hamayun245

  • 9 years ago

  #62 Feedback please ! Thanks :)

  • 9 years ago
  View 2 more messages
  1. 

     Ruelll

     • 9 years ago

     Plus the image should fit the disc box, you didn`t even deign to resize that.

     • 9 years ago
  2. 
     Contest Holder

     • 9 years ago

     Not cool, dude. NOT COOL. Fortunately Addam thought it looked familiar. http://goo.gl/OFdHA
     
     Withdraw from this contest before I report you.

     • 9 years ago
• 
  Contest Holder

  • 9 years ago

  I have sent you all private comments to your submissions. Please check and let me know if you have not received feedback.

  • 9 years ago

Show more comments